The other day a new dog owner asked for my advice about what to feed a dog. Bluebelle has been eating mainly paleo after her first year, when she seemed to be getting health problems from a diet of dried food and mince. These included trouble pooing and stiff hips or sore legs. She no longer has any of these problems, but we did have an issue with iodine deficiency on the new diet - see below.
![]()
A mainly carnivorous animal like Bluebelle (to wit, a dog) needs to eat muscle,
connective tissue (gristle and skin), bones, organ meats, and fat to be
healthy, from a range of animals including some fish. It is an omnivore and can
tolerate some carbohydrate from starches and fruit, but should not have
grain-based dry food often (OK for emergencies but not as regular diet).
In terms of calories there needs to be 4-5 parts fat to 1 part protein.
Fat is much denser than protein and all meat has some fat in it, so this mostly
means using fatty meats or adding a little fat to the dish.
Kelp powder should also be added to the food occasionally to prevent
iodine deficiency and hypothyroidism (we learned this the hard way), and salt
added to cooked meals.
Symptoms of low iodine include “spooky” behaviour and depression, hair loss, discoloured patches on skin, and in Bluebelle’s case susceptibility to mastitis and allergies and hunched, stiff “aged” posture. This was quickly and completely reversed by kelp, which had a rejuvenating effect like watering a wilting plant. This was only diagnosed by my habit of reading the excellent Hyperlipid blog of vet Peter Dobromylskyj, who mentioned the symptoms in passing, for which I'm eternally grateful; our vet had drugs for the symptoms but didn’t recognise the cause.
Symptoms of low iodine include “spooky” behaviour and depression, hair loss, discoloured patches on skin, and in Bluebelle’s case susceptibility to mastitis and allergies and hunched, stiff “aged” posture. This was quickly and completely reversed by kelp, which had a rejuvenating effect like watering a wilting plant. This was only diagnosed by my habit of reading the excellent Hyperlipid blog of vet Peter Dobromylskyj, who mentioned the symptoms in passing, for which I'm eternally grateful; our vet had drugs for the symptoms but didn’t recognise the cause.
Onions and garlic can be toxic to dogs (and cats, causing Heinz body anaemia) but most other veges are safe
(and they will generally avoid onions anyway) when feeding leftover meat
dishes. The inability to detoxify onions tells you that a dog is not as completely
omnivorous as say a pig or human and its ancestors probably never survived by
eating roots, shoots and leaves. Though, come to think of it, my goat wouldn't eat onions either. Gophers like them, apparently, and pigs aren't harmed by them (though some warn against feeding onions to pigs, research seems to show benefits).
We feed Blubelle:
Minced beef and lamb
Beef (ox) heart, lamb heart, cut into cubes, raw
Offal: Liver or kidney (lambs or calves or ox or chicken) COOKED
(lightly fried in dripping with salt, once or twice a week). If we don’t
include some salt, Bluebelle drinks more sea water, and not all dogs have
access to salt water.
Note: pork hearts tend to be flabby, pork kidneys I’ve bought have been
deformed, coming from caged animals, so I don’t generally buy these or
commercial lard. A bit of bacon scrap accounts for most of the pork in her
diet.
Bones - beef bones probably best, also chicken necks, raw.
Kelp powder - a small teaspoon mixed in or sprinkled on food every few
days.
Fats - we add a couple of tablespoons dripping (beef and lamb) or if
available, free-range lard, to the less fatty meals. If the dog eats dripping
(tallow in the U.S.), which is fairly flavourless, then it definitely needs fat.
Bacon rinds or bacon grease and offcuts of the meat you prepare for yourself
are also good.
Fish - a tin or sardines or half a tin of mackerel once a week keeps the
coat shiny.
Chicken - we feed Bluebelle our roast chicken leftovers, including the bones. This may not be for every dog but it hasn't done her any
harm.
Cheese - Bluebelle loves cheese, and
enjoys milk and cream and yoghurt every so often. When the milk's a bit off,
offer it to the dog. Probably not an everyday food though.
Fruit - Bluebelle likes a few raisins
or diced prunes occasionally. Other dogs like apples and pear cores, but she
doesn't seem to. She won't eat potatoes or rice or cooked greens unless these are stirred into meat, so we don't offer these unless there's a very meaty leftover stew.
Dried food - Bluebelle eats toast crusts
occasionally and will eat dog biscuits if there's nothing else, so it's a good
emergency food occasionally, but it wasn't good for her digestion when she ate
it more often. If you get a dog roll, I recommend looking out for the rice-based
(gluten-free) versions, or for dog rolls higher in fat and lower in
carbohydrate.
Water - Bluebelle doesn't always
drink water, but when she does, she needs a lot, so always have some available.
Timing - Bluebelle is fed once a day, in the evening. If she's not interested in food, she's not fed until she asks for it; so every now and then she goes without. She's fed about a pound or more a day; if she asks for more, she'll get it. She might turn up if someone is eating cheese, in which case she'll always be given a bit, and any uneaten or old cheese (cheddar) is given to her.
Illness - it's probably worth giving a little cod liver oil in winter for vitamin D, Bluebelle loves this; just a teaspoon a day.
Parvovirus and distemper are lethal diseases of dogs which are similar to cholera in humans. The dog dies of dehydration, loss of fluids and electrolytes. Dogs can be kept alive till the disease passes (about a week) by force-feeding, twice a day, water and Gastrolyte, or other human "oral rehydration" formula (made up strictly as advised on the packet). I have saved two dogs suffering from parvovirus by this protocol; the dog that received the formula as soon as it became ill suffered no lasting effects, the other dog, which I treated after 3 days, was always a bit skinny afterwards. Another dog that was accidentally taken to the vet and received antibiotics, not rehydration (which a vet could give by IV drip), died there.
I don't know why this isn't widely known.
I'm sure this is a case where many readers will have dogs with unusual dietary needs, or have had experience of deficiencies, diseases and toxins that we can all learn from, so feel free to use the Comments facility. I think my own ideas are working well, but I don't consider them the last word yet.
Timing - Bluebelle is fed once a day, in the evening. If she's not interested in food, she's not fed until she asks for it; so every now and then she goes without. She's fed about a pound or more a day; if she asks for more, she'll get it. She might turn up if someone is eating cheese, in which case she'll always be given a bit, and any uneaten or old cheese (cheddar) is given to her.
Illness - it's probably worth giving a little cod liver oil in winter for vitamin D, Bluebelle loves this; just a teaspoon a day.
Parvovirus and distemper are lethal diseases of dogs which are similar to cholera in humans. The dog dies of dehydration, loss of fluids and electrolytes. Dogs can be kept alive till the disease passes (about a week) by force-feeding, twice a day, water and Gastrolyte, or other human "oral rehydration" formula (made up strictly as advised on the packet). I have saved two dogs suffering from parvovirus by this protocol; the dog that received the formula as soon as it became ill suffered no lasting effects, the other dog, which I treated after 3 days, was always a bit skinny afterwards. Another dog that was accidentally taken to the vet and received antibiotics, not rehydration (which a vet could give by IV drip), died there.
I don't know why this isn't widely known.
I'm sure this is a case where many readers will have dogs with unusual dietary needs, or have had experience of deficiencies, diseases and toxins that we can all learn from, so feel free to use the Comments facility. I think my own ideas are working well, but I don't consider them the last word yet.